Sunday, August 01, 2010

Discovering Haiti

One of my favorite lectures to give in my World History 2 class is the one on Haiti. Especially since the earthquake there earlier this year, I find it truly important to break the silence that surrounds Haiti and its revolutionary history. I was appalled at how through months of coverage over Haiti by media in the United States, the narrative was always the same, tragedy in a third world country. Collapse in a place where collapse and disaster is a way of life. The valiant efforts by the first world in recognizing that suffering and taking steps to alleviate it, to help those helpless souls. Given the scent of human suffering its understandable that they take this angle, but what was left out of their coverage, the historical aspects was also expected but still nonetheless horrifying to watch (or rather to not watch).
The media's purpose in this case was to help the people of the US "discover" Haiti. the concept of discovery is always interesting. It has the aura of learning something new, but in truth this newness is just an illusion, and it acts in such a way to reinforce something you already believe or assume. So the media's helping people "discovery" Haiti was not an attempt to teach something new to the people of the US, to tell them things which they didn't already know about Haiti, but rather teach them things they didn't know they already knew about Haiti. So imagined destitution and poverty, the existing suffering, all these already assumed things were given even more depth, more details, more graphic imagery or even simple anecdotes to sustain them. As a result people learned what they already know about poor black underdeveloped nations. They found what they already suspected even prior to knowing anything to be sad, but true.

What was of course completely absent was the role that the US has long played in keeping Haiti a poor and violent place. This role has been ongoing for centuries, and has included several dozen instances where the US landed troops on the island and US Marines literally running its government. It has also helped create and nurture different dictators who have terrorized the country as well. All of this was on behalf of different US economic interests in the island. It is important to note that this is not something abstract or remote, like some silly exceptional lark in the past which doesn't mean much in terms of how we should "really" think of the US and what it has done to the world. That link is something which you can find evidenced in suffering, blood, poverty, it is something which should have been included in every report in Haiti to the United States; that this country you are "discovering" its state is something you own, it is something that belongs to you and should be considered the inheritance of the United States, just as much as any claim to freedom or democracy.
But that is one of the most ironic and tragic things about Haiti, is that the way history has tormented it, the revolutionary and historic potential that it once represented is all but lost. The most successful slave revolt in history, which led to the creation of one of the most radical foundations upon which a modern republic was based in the 19th century, has been reduced to rubble by the first world for centuries. As Michel Rolph Truillot argues in Silencing the Past, the Haitian Revolution and defeat of three European powers to eradicate slavery on Hispanola, was something which was unthinkable and unimaginable by Europeans. It was the logical and rational extension of their so-called Enlightenment that all men should have reason, should be free and should be able to govern themselves, and so that should include literally ALL PEOPLE, including women of all colors and men of all colors. But every white or European country or philosopher found some way to exclude the rest of the world and women from the equation, some flimsy racist or sexist excuse to argue that people who work with their hands have less reason than rich people, or black people have less intelligence and less reason than white people, or the fact that women menstruate means they cannot be trusted with rights or political power. The Haitian Revolution was slaves and freed slaves fighting for equality and their freedom and winning, and producing a constitution which instead of incorporating slavery or ignoring the blatant contradiction, abolished the institution entirely. It was the closest to real human freedom that any republic had gotten, and because it had done with nearly all white men refused to even touch, it had to be forgotten, it had to be covered over with misery, and the history of Haiti since that point has been various First World countries ensuring that no one would know of that historical achievement, and all that they would "discover" when they looked at Haiti were masses of black bodies who have failed to govern and develop themselves.

I came across the article below from the blog Indigenist Opinion, which discusses the roles that Cubans have been playing in helping rebuild Haiti after its earthquake.


Cuba has not forgotten Haiti
Havana. July 29, 2010
Leticia Martínez Hernández

SIX months have passed, but it seems like yesterday when, on that January 12, the faces of this agitated, forgetful world turned toward Haiti, the poorest nation of the American continent. Then the earth was shaking infernally and the international community lamented the tragedy that had befallen the nation of Toussaint L’Ouverture.

The people who breathed their last breath amounted to hundreds of thousands, and one million lost the roofs of their homes in which they spent their nights and sheltered from the sun and showers… Six months after the earthquake that devastated Port-au-Prince, more than one million people are still sleeping rough in tents and waking up to despair despite the promised aid from many countries. Six months after the earthquake “the dance of the millions” continues without it materializing, and the gestures of goodbye are becoming commonplace.

The Haitian capital is still an immense refugee camp, with more than 1,300 camps that have become `stable residencies’ for those who have lost everything, and every morning they go off to find ways of surviving in a country where options of work, apart from the informal markets, are becoming more and more elusive.

Meanwhile, the rubble remains impassable, the dumps constant fixtures, the rainy season is threatening, illnesses are lying in wait, forests are disappearing and uncertainty is overpowering a nation extremely lacerated after so many years of capitalist exploitation.

However, the world has once again turned its back on Haiti. One figure is enough to back up this hypothesis: the country has only received 2% of the close to $10 billion that the international community promised to donate for its reconstruction.

And so the prophetic words of Comandante en Jefe Fidel Castro in his Reflection of January 16 resound with a hard truth: “In Haiti, it will be put to the test how long the spirit of cooperation will endure before egotism, chauvinism, petty interests and contempt for other nations prevail.”

While some are turning the page on the tragedy of Haiti, Cuba does not want to forget, it cannot do so, because more than 11 years of work there have made it understand the value of a hand extended in time, like that of the night of January 12 when the first hospital to give help to the wounded of the earthquake was that of the Cubans, or when, in 2008, merciless rain buried the city of Gonaïves in the mire and the corpses reached into the hundreds, and only the Cuban doctors weighed anchor there in order to help save lives and share the same fate as the Haitians. For this reason, it doesn’t seem strange or, even less, an exaggeration that in response to an inquiry about the doings of our doctors, many Haitians will say, totally naturally, “After God come the Cubans.”

Thus, another figure is more demonstrative. When the earth shook in Haiti, 331 Cuban doctors were already there, and their numbers now stand at 1,010 between Cubans and graduates of the Latin American School of Medicine, attending to anyone at any hour of the day or night. They are striving to totally reconstruct the collapsed health system which, in a few years, will provide coverage for more than 75% of the population: a dream until yesterday prohibited for those without sufficient gourdes (national currency) to enter health institutions, even for a simple injection.

For that reason little Kevens of Haiti is eternally grateful for the prosthesis that will give him the chance to play Ronaldinho-style football again; and 70-year-old grandfather Paul Benito, whose health has always been neglected, is dumbfounded by the fact that when his high blood pressure took him to the brink of death, the Cuban doctors treated him without asking for anything in exchange.

This is how it has been since 1998, when Hurricane George devastated Haiti and our medics planted their flag for the first time in this much-lashed nation.

From that time, many are the stories recounted about that enduring love, like that of Logista, a beautiful young woman who lost both her legs in the earthquake and arrived at the hospital with a hemoglobin level of two and medical nurse José Enrique gave her a blood donation so that she could smile again.

Today this young woman is more alive than ever and the Cuban doctors are teaching her to walk again with prostheses sent from Cuba. How to forget the joy of Mackende in La Renaissance Hospital in Port-au-Prince, when Nurse Marlene Jorge, “his other mom,” visited him every afternoon in the ward where he was awaiting an operation on his leg. The child had lost all of his family in the earthquake and only had the Cuban medics for company.

That simple and sensitive is our aid in Haiti, acts of help forgotten more than once by those who are constantly involved in their Herculean task, even when the total of patients treated after the earthquake is in the vicinity of 500,000; when approximately 180,000 Haitians are finding relief in 30 rehabilitation rooms; when more than 150,000 operations have been performed; when more than 125,000 people have been immunized; when prosthesis and electro-medicine workshops are materializing or when 22 community referral hospitals are functioning thanks to Cuba and the countries of the ALBA (Bolivarian Alliance for the Peoples of Our America).

And as if that was nothing, other groups of Cubans are building houses and setting up fish farms, teaching literacy, or restoring to life an abandoned sugar mill… They are the architects, engineers, teachers, veterinarians, fishers and sugar-cane workers who, alongside the medical brigade, are giving lessons in lasting aid, aid with a view to the future that will end the avalanche of “band aids” which conceal the wounds of Haiti every year.

Six months have gone by, even though it seems like yesterday. Port-au-Prince and its surrounding areas remain the seat of “the inferno of this world,” in which so many people are surviving in infrahuman conditions without any idea whatsoever of how long the punishment will last.

Meanwhile, the world continues to suffer from amnesia, and the peoples, as Fidel wrote this past January 16; “will be increasingly harsher and more implacable” in their criticisms. But there are still those who believe in the future of Haiti, of that beloved Haiti captured in a famous song, of that Haiti which is discovering the smiles of its children, perhaps a joyful presage of a future that, of necessity, has to be better.


Anonymous said...

Learning makes a good man better and ill man worse.............................................................

Anonymous said...


Hem said...



Related Posts with Thumbnails